The government's own data shows trans women are at risk
The UK government's own Equality Impact Assessment warns that forcing trans women to use men's services puts them at disproportionate risk of violence and sexual assault. It also flags increased harassment for anyone who does not conform to gender stereotypes. The government is pushing ahead anyway, and that contradiction deserves a direct answer.
By Dr Helen Webberley4 June 20266 min read
The UK government's own Equality Impact Assessment warns that forcing trans women to use men's services puts them at disproportionate risk of violence and sexual assault. It also flags that anyone who does not conform to gender stereotypes faces increased harassment. The government is pushing ahead anyway, and that contradiction deserves a direct answer.
What does the government's own evidence actually say?
This is not a campaigner's claim or an advocacy group's projection. The Equality Impact Assessment is a document produced by the government itself, as part of the standard process for assessing whether a policy change will cause harm. It found that requiring trans women to use male spaces increases their exposure to violence and sexual assault. It found that people who simply do not look the way others expect a man or woman to look, whether or not they are trans, will face more harassment as a result of enforcement.
When a government commissions evidence and then disregards it in the same policy cycle, that is not an oversight. It is a choice. And the people who pay for that choice are trans women, and others who do not fit a narrow idea of what bodies are supposed to look like.
Why is the government pushing ahead?
I keep asking myself this. The political context matters: the current Labour government is responding to a Supreme Court ruling that interpreted the Equality Act 2010 as defining "woman" by reference to a birth certificate. That ruling has been widely criticised, including by legal scholars, as inconsistent with Parliament's original intent. But a court ruling is an interpretation of a statute, not a rewrite of it. The statute still stands.
What followed the ruling, though, was guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) that has itself been widely criticised as confusing, contradictory, and in some places unworkable. That guidance is now being treated as though it were law. It is not. It is guidance, and guidance can be withdrawn.
Nadia, whose words opened the video that sits alongside this piece, asked the question I think cuts through all of it: "Why not instead withdraw the guidance and legislate to clarify that the Equality Act was always intended to be trans inclusive?"
It is a good question. It is, in fact, the right question. And the answer the government has given, which amounts to "the Supreme Court has spoken, and we are implementing that", does not engage with it honestly.
Fact-checking the government's framing on trans rights
The government's response to public petitions on this issue has leaned on a particular framing: that the Supreme Court ruling settled the legal question, that the guidance reflects the law, and that the process is being handled fairly and carefully. Each of those claims is worth examining.
The Supreme Court ruling settled the legal question. It did not. It settled one court's interpretation of the Equality Act 2010 in one specific context. Courts interpret statutes; they do not rewrite them. Parliament has the power to legislate and to clarify, and that power has not been used. Treating a contested interpretation as settled fact is a political choice, not a legal necessity.
The guidance reflects the law. The EHRC guidance that followed the ruling has been criticised by lawyers, equalities experts, and the Scottish Government, among others, for being inconsistent and in places unworkable. Guidance issued by the EHRC carries significant weight, but it does not have the force of statute. Presenting it as though it does is misleading.
The process is being handled fairly and carefully. If it were, the government would not be in the position of ignoring its own Equality Impact Assessment. A fair and careful process takes its own evidence seriously.
The history the government seems to want to forget
The Equality Act 2010 was passed by the last Labour government. It was passed after that same Labour government passed the Gender Recognition Act in 2004, which formally recognised trans people in UK law for the first time. Those two Acts sit together in legal history. Parliament knew trans people existed, knew they had legal recognition, and passed an Equalities Act in that context.
The argument that Parliament never intended the Equality Act to protect trans people is not just legally contested. It is historically implausible. Trans people were not an afterthought. They were already part of the legal landscape when the Act was written.
The characteristic protected under the Equality Act 2010 is "gender reassignment," and it has never required a Gender Recognition Certificate to engage. People have been protected under that characteristic for over a decade, in employment, services, and public life. The Supreme Court ruling changed one interpretation in one area. It did not erase that history.
How can the EHRC get this right?
The EHRC exists to protect and promote equality and human rights for everyone. That mission includes trans people. Here is what getting this right would actually look like.
First, withdraw the current guidance and replace it with something workable. The guidance as it stands has created confusion across public services, schools, leisure centres, and workplaces. Organisations do not know what they are permitted to do. That is not a minor administrative inconvenience: it is actively harming trans people who are losing access to services they had before.
Second, take the Equality Impact Assessment seriously. If the EHRC is advising on guidance that the government's own evidence says will increase violence and harassment, the EHRC has a duty to say so clearly and loudly, not to produce guidance that enables it.
Third, engage with the legal argument honestly. The EHRC should be making the case to government that Parliament has the power to legislate, and that legislating to clarify the trans-inclusive intent of the Equality Act is available, proportionate, and consistent with the UK's obligations under international human rights law, including the European Convention on Human Rights.
Fourth, stop treating single-sex services as the only equality question in the room. The guidance has focused almost exclusively on spaces. It has said almost nothing about the safety of trans people being excluded from those spaces, even though the government's own evidence flags that as the more acute risk. Equality law is supposed to balance competing interests, not treat one group's interests as though they automatically override another's.
What should the government do?
Nadia's suggestion is the right one. Withdraw the guidance. Then legislate.
Legislating to clarify that the Equality Act was always intended to be trans inclusive would not require a dramatic overhaul of equality law. It would require Parliament to say, in plain terms, what many lawyers already argue was intended: that trans women are women for the purposes of the Act, that trans men are men, and that the characteristic of gender reassignment protects trans people from discrimination and harassment across all the areas the Act covers.
This is not a radical ask. It is the ask that a government serious about equality would have made the moment a Supreme Court ruling began to be used as a lever to remove protections from a minority group. The fact that it has not been made tells us something about political will, not about legal possibility.
Trans women are at risk. The government's own document says so. The question is whether the government will act on its own evidence, or continue to explain why the evidence does not change what it had already decided to do.
If there is a topic that you would like me to cover, just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert, Medical Educator, and advocate for trans equality.
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments