London Assembly calls EHRC guidance discriminatory and unworkable

The London Assembly has condemned the EHRC's revised Code of Practice as discriminatory, contradictory, and unworkable, calling on London MPs to sign Early Day Motion 240 and push back before the guidance takes hold. The motion passed with cross-party support, making clear that elected representatives, not only campaign groups, are now pushing back on guidance that would upend trans people's everyday lives.

By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to london.gov.uk24 July 20265 min read

London Assembly calls EHRC guidance discriminatory and unworkable

Photo by Jonny Gios on Unsplash

The London Assembly has formally passed a motion condemning the Equality and Human Rights Commission's revised Code of Practice as contradictory, discriminatory, and unworkable. The motion called on London MPs to sign Early Day Motion 240 and urged the Mayor of London and the Chair of the Assembly to write to those MPs encouraging them to intervene before the guidance is adopted. Fourteen London MPs had already signed the motion before the Assembly vote, including Stella Creasy, Dawn Butler, Diane Abbott, Jeremy Corbyn, and Emily Thornberry. The vote passed six to five.

Elected representatives, in a formal chamber, on the record, have looked at what the EHRC has produced and called it what it is. Not cautiously. Not with the usual hedging that comes when politicians enter this territory. Benali Hamdache, who proposed the motion, said plainly that the guidance is unworkable and risks worsening an already difficult climate for trans people who continue to face significant discrimination and disadvantage. The Assembly agreed.

What the guidance would actually do

The EHRC's revised Code of Practice followed the Supreme Court's ruling on the Equality Act 2010. The court's interpretation, not the Act itself, was the trigger. The guidance that came out of that interpretation has been widely criticised for being confusing and internally inconsistent, and the London Assembly's motion makes that point directly.

What worries me most, and what the motion captures well, is the practical consequence for ordinary life. Trans people's everyday lives would be upended without safe and convenient access to toilets, changing rooms, and other public services. That is the Assembly's language, not mine, and they are right. We are talking about a person who needs to use a public toilet on their lunch break. A teenager changing after sport. Someone attending a medical appointment. The guidance, if adopted and enforced as written, turns those ordinary moments into something fraught, contested, and potentially hostile.

The motion also names something that tends to get lost in the abstract policy debate: the guidance does not just affect trans people. It creates a climate where service providers and members of the public feel they can and must police gender and sex, based on blunt, surface-level assessments of femininity and masculinity. That harms trans people, gender-diverse people, and cisgender people who do not fit a narrow physical template. The Assembly said it. I have been saying it for years. It matters that it is now in a formal motion passed by a democratically elected body.

What the EHRC's own research shows

Here is the part that should embarrass the EHRC most. The Assembly's motion cites the EHRC's own previous research: 62 per cent of trans people had experienced transphobic harassment from strangers in public. The body whose job it is to protect people from harassment has now produced guidance that, in the Assembly's view, risks entrenching that experience. The contradiction is not subtle. A regulator that knows the scale of the problem and then issues guidance that makes the problem worse is not doing its job.

Why elected opposition matters at this moment

There has been no shortage of voices opposing this guidance. Trans rights organisations, trade unions, legal practitioners, and campaign groups have all set out in detail why the Code of Practice is flawed. What the London Assembly vote adds is something different in kind. It places opposition inside a formal democratic institution, with a vote count attached and names on the record.

That matters for several reasons. It gives MPs political cover to act, because they can point to cross-party elected support rather than positioning themselves as outliers. It makes the EHRC's defence of the guidance harder, because the criticism is now coming from a body whose legitimacy is harder to dismiss. And it gives trans people something concrete: not a petition, not a campaign, but a resolution passed in a chamber, with the names of the London MPs who have already signed the supporting Early Day Motion listed in the text.

Fourteen names. Fourteen people who have put their support on record. That number will either grow or it will not, and how it moves will tell us something important about where parliamentary opinion on this actually sits, beneath the noise.

What trans people should take from this

The Assembly's motion also asks the Greater London Authority to report back, if the Code is adopted, on how it plans to interpret and enforce the guidance. That is a practical piece of accountability, and it signals that those who passed this motion intend to keep watching. The motion is not the end of this; it is a marker in a longer fight.

What I want trans people to hear is this: the political landscape is not monolithic. The voices calling this guidance out for what it is are inside formal institutions now, not only outside them. That does not make the guidance safe or the situation anything other than serious. But it means the pressure being applied is the kind that can actually change outcomes, and that is worth knowing.

The EHRC was supposed to be the body trans people could rely on to protect them. Right now, it is an elected assembly filling that gap. That is not how it should be. But the Assembly stepped up, and that deserves to be recognised.

If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.

Dr Helen Webberley is a gender expert, medical educator, and advocate for trans people and their families.

In response toCalls for protection of trans people in wake of new EHRC guidancelondon.gov.uk

Talk it through with Sammy

Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Everything here is education, not medical advice. If you're in crisis, call your local emergency services or visit helenwebberley.com/heretohelp.