Camas trans runner qualifies for state, and the protestors stay home

By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to The Seattle Times3 November 20264 min read

A transgender girl led Camas High School's cross-country team to a state qualifier finish at the Westside Classic regional meet, placing seventh overall with a time of 18:49.5. Her team placed fourth. No runners walked off the start line. She qualified for state and that is the whole story, except for the adults still trying to make it something else.

Camas trans runner qualifies for state, and the protestors stay home

Photo by Peter Robbins on Unsplash

A transgender girl helped the Camas High School cross-country team qualify for the Washington state championship meet, finishing seventh overall at the Westside Classic regional race with a time of 18:49.5. Her team placed fourth. No runners walked off the start line. She qualified for state and that is the whole story, except for the adults still trying to make it something else.

What happened at Chambers Bay

Saturday's Westside Classic regional race at Chambers Bay Golf Course brought athletes from across the state together for one of the last chances to make the state meet. Curtis High School's Charlotte White won the 4A girls varsity race outright, in 18:21.6, a genuinely strong performance that barely registered in the coverage. Camas placed fourth as a team, with an average time of 19:42.9, and seven teams in total advanced. The Camas runner at the centre of a month of online fury ran a solid 18:49.5 and helped get her team through.

That is it. That is what happened. A teenager ran well, her team qualified, and everyone got on with their afternoon.

The Seattle Times observed about a dozen adults in opposition T-shirts at the race. No runners walked off the start line. The protest had shrunk from something that stopped a meet and needed police barricades to a small group of grown-ups in matching shirts watching children run. The children did not seem particularly interested in them.

From district title to state qualifier

If you read the earlier piece here, you know where this team has been. The district meet on 21 October, moved to Camas' home course because of security concerns, saw barricades, a police presence, and a rally. Thirteen runners walked off a start line in October. A group of senior girls ended their season early. The girl at the centre of it ran past signs and noise and still finished second. Her team won the district title.

Now they have qualified for state. And the walkouts did not happen at the regional. That shift is worth noticing, not because the opposition has gone away, the ballot initiative is still live, but because the teenagers on that start line made a different choice when the moment came. Whatever was said to them in the weeks before, on Saturday they ran together.

What Initiative 638 would actually do

Washington voters will decide on Initiative 638 on 3 November, four days before the state championship meet on 7 November. The initiative, bankrolled by hedge fund manager Brian Heywood and sponsored by Let's Go Washington, would ban transgender girls from competing with other girls in public K-12 athletics. It would also require every student wanting to compete in girls' sport to submit medical documentation, confirmation through reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or testosterone levels.

Every girl. Not every trans girl. Every girl who wants to play.

Proponents say it protects the integrity of women's sport. What it actually does is make every girl prove she belongs before she can join her team. The WIAA says there are no more than ten transgender athletes competing in the entire state in any given year, out of roughly 225,000 students. Ten. The infrastructure of suspicion this initiative would build, the documentation, the examinations, the bureaucratic gatekeeping, would land on all 225,000 of them in order to reach those ten.

That has always been the part that gets buried. A measure framed as protecting girls would make sport harder for every girl in Washington. Trans girls are girls, and a rule that demands girls prove it hurts all of them.

The quietness is the point

I keep thinking about what it means that no one walked off on Saturday. Not because the opposition had converted, or because the politics had shifted, but because the race happened and it was just a race. The adults with their shirts were there, and the teenagers ran anyway, and the times were recorded, and the qualifying spots were awarded, and the conversation in the coaching tent afterwards was probably about the state course and what to eat the night before and whether the weather would hold.

That is what inclusion looks like when it is working. Not a ceremony, not a statement. Just a girl on a cross-country course doing what she trained to do, with her team around her.

She is a minor. The Seattle Times has not named her because she has not consented to be identified, and neither will I. What I will say is that she has run this entire season with millions of strangers forming opinions about her existence, with protests at her races and signs on the course and teammates who walked away from her. She ran at regionals and she qualified for state. I hope the state meet feels like the one where it gets to be just about running.

In response toCamas cross-country team, transgender girl qualify for stateThe Seattle Times

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Talk to Sammy