B.C. doctor ordered to pay $28,100 for refusing trans teen's puberty blocker injection

By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to CBC10 September 20265 min read

The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal has ordered family doctor Henry Ajaero to pay $28,100 after he refused to inject a transgender teenager with a prescribed puberty blocker, Lupron, citing religious and cultural reasons. The tribunal found his refusal was discriminatory and that he had not established any genuine conflict between his beliefs and the medical service the teen needed.

B.C. doctor ordered to pay $28,100 for refusing trans teen's puberty blocker injection

Photo by Navy Medicine on Unsplash

The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal has ordered family doctor Henry Ajaero to pay $28,100 after he refused to inject a transgender teenager with a prescribed puberty blocker, Lupron, citing religious and cultural reasons. The tribunal found his refusal was discriminatory and that he had not established any genuine conflict between his beliefs and the medical service the teen needed.

The day she described as one of the best of her life

I want to start with Child Q, because she is the person this story is about.

She came out as transgender in late 2020, at fourteen, and began struggling with her mental health as puberty started. Her family doctor referred her to the B.C. Gender Clinic, where an endocrinologist prescribed Lupron, a medication that pauses puberty. The decision describes the day she started the medication as "one of the best days of my life." That is not a small thing, but a teenager, already dealing with an unwanted puberty, finally getting access to something that gave her breathing room.

Lupron needs to be injected every three to four weeks. Child Q and her family preferred to have it done by a doctor rather than at home, which is entirely reasonable. So they made an appointment at the family practice for 5 March 2021. They turned up. They waited. And then, when Dr Ajaero saw the name of the medication, he called Child Q's mother into the room and told her he would not be administering it. For religious and cultural reasons. He "hoped that was OK." Her mother told him it was not.

Child Q and her mother never spoke with Dr Ajaero again outside of legal proceedings.

What the tribunal actually found

Dr Ajaero argued two things: that administering the injection would conflict with his religious belief that "God created man and woman," and that it was outside the scope of his practice. The tribunal dismissed both.

On the religious argument, the tribunal found that Lupron is not a gender reassignment medication. It pauses puberty. It does not, on its own, do anything that conflicts with the stated belief. The tribunal was direct: Dr Ajaero had not established that a genuine conflict existed. His standards, as the decision puts it, "were developed quickly, in the context of a busy and stressful day, with incomplete information." That context explains what happened, but does not justify it.

On the expertise argument, Dr Ajaero had never administered Lupron before, had never worked with a trans patient to his knowledge, and said he felt "uncomfortable and unprepared." The tribunal accepted that those feelings were real and that he was not acting from malicious intent. It still found he had discriminated against Child Q because of her gender identity. Discomfort is not a clinical defence, and it is not a legal one either.

Conscience is not a shield

I have heard versions of this argument many times. A clinician says they are not equipped, or not comfortable, or that their faith prevents them. Sometimes that is genuine. But there is a difference between declining to perform a complex procedure outside your competence and refusing to administer a medication that has already been prescribed, by a specialist, for a patient sitting in your waiting room.

Child Q was not asking Dr Ajaero to diagnose her, assess her, or make any clinical judgement about her gender. She had already been through the Gender Clinic. A specialist had already prescribed her medication. She needed an injection. That is a routine task for any family doctor. The "outside my expertise" argument collapses the moment you look at what was actually being asked.

And the religious argument, as the tribunal noted, rests on a mischaracterisation of what Lupron does. It pauses puberty. It is the same medication used in children experiencing precocious puberty, a use that has existed for decades. Dr Ajaero's notes from the appointment describe it as medication "for gender re-assignment." The tribunal found that framing was simply wrong.

What this ruling costs, and what it means

Dr Ajaero has been ordered to pay $28,100 in compensation. He also applied to the tribunal to have his name and clinic kept out of the public record, arguing that doctors who provide gender-affirming care face threats. The tribunal denied that application, noting there is no evidence that doctors who refuse to give gender-affirming care face the same risks. That is a pointed observation, and a fair one.

The ruling matters beyond this one appointment. Every clinician who has considered using religion or discomfort as a reason to turn a trans patient away now has a clear answer from a human rights tribunal. The answer is no. You cannot refuse to administer a prescribed medication to a trans teenager and call it conscience, only what the tribunal called it: discrimination.

For Child Q, described in the decision as "a brave, sensitive, kind transgender girl," none of this undoes the day she sat in a waiting room and was sent away by the person who was supposed to care for her. Compensation cannot give that back. What it can do is make clear to the next doctor, and the one after that, that trans patients are entitled to the same standard of care as anyone else. Full stop.

In response toHuman Rights Tribunal orders B.C. doctor to pay after refusing to provide trans teen with puberty blocker shotCBC

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Talk to Sammy