Gender identity language was invented because people disliked saying sex

Back to all 18 myths

Myth 14:03 to 14:11 inaccurate

Gender identity language was invented because people disliked saying sex

Andrew Gold said:

“My understanding was we started using the word gender because people felt a bit funny about saying the word sex, they don't like saying this, they use gender, so it's just a synonym for sex.”
Why it sounds convincing

It sounds like a plausible piece of social history: euphemism is a real phenomenon in language, and many people do use sex and gender interchangeably in everyday speech.

Truth

The distinction between sex and gender was not coined because people were squeamish about a three-letter word. Researchers in medicine and psychology developed it deliberately in the 1950s and 1960s precisely to separate biological characteristics from the social roles and psychological identity that do not map neatly onto them, and feminist theorists took it up for the same reason. The distinction did real intellectual work, which is why it was eventually written into international health classifications and into UK law, where the Equality Act 2010 lists sex and gender reassignment as two separate protected characteristics rather than treating them as the same thing. When the two are folded back into a synonym, every policy and clinical conversation that depends on telling them apart becomes impossible to follow, and the people navigating those conversations in real life are the ones who lose.

Anyone trying to understand the policy and clinical debate, because collapsing the distinction makes it impossible to reason clearly about what is actually being discussed.

Back to Heretics: the gender debate, with Andrew Gold

Whatever brought you here, I'm glad you came. Tell me what is on your mind and we can talk it through.

Sammy is an AI companion, taught by Helen. What that means

Talk to Sammy