Most children who identify as trans grow out of it

Back to all 9 myths

Myth 12:02 to 12:15 misleading

Most children who identify as trans grow out of it

Julia Hartley-Brewer said:

“the vast majority of the the vast majority of the children who, if they're left to their own devices, either, quote, grow out of this, go and live a perfectly happy, healthy life as gay men or lesbian women.”
Why it sounds convincing

Older studies did report high rates of desistance in children referred to gender clinics, and this figure has been widely repeated in media coverage, giving it the feel of established fact.

Truth

The studies behind that figure counted children who would not meet today's clinical criteria for a persistent gender identity: many were referred for gender nonconformity rather than a consistent, insistent sense of being a different gender, and a significant proportion were later understood to be gay or lesbian cisgender children, which is precisely the conflation the claim relies on. When researchers look specifically at children who do meet current criteria, the desistance rates are considerably lower, and the framing of sexual orientation as the natural landing place for those who desist treats two entirely separate characteristics as though one were a corrected version of the other. The older figure has been repeated often enough that it carries the weight of established fact, but the methodology behind it has been examined and found wanting by researchers in this field. Families who hold back support on the strength of it are not giving their child time to settle: they are withholding affirmation from a child who may carry the cost of that in mental health and physical development for the rest of their life.

Trans adolescents whose families withhold support on the basis that they will probably grow out of it, delaying or denying care during a critical developmental period.

Back to TalkTV: the conversion therapy ban, with Julia Hartley-Brewer

Whatever brought you here, I'm glad you came. Tell me what is on your mind and we can talk it through.

Sammy is an AI companion, taught by Helen. What that means

Talk to Sammy