What Cass told Parliament about the conversion practices bill

On 16 November 2026, Baroness Cass told the Joint Committee scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill that it is not "anywhere near tight enough" to avoid unintended consequences. Most of her evidence concerned risks to clinicians and parents. I think the bill should protect trans young people first.

By Dr Helen Webberley17 November 20267 min read

What did Cass say to the Joint Committee on conversion practices?

The Joint Committee was appointed to consider the government's draft Conversion Practices Bill, which sets out provisions to prevent and criminalise abusive and harmful conversion practices. Conversion practices are attempts to change or suppress a person's sexual orientation or gender identity. The committee was taking oral evidence, which means witnesses answer questions in person, and Baroness Cass was one of two witnesses that afternoon. She introduced herself as the chair of the Independent Review of Gender Services for Children and Young People, the review that took her name, and as an independent adviser to the Department of Health and Social Care.

She explained why her position looked different from her earlier public comment. She had welcomed the principles of the bill after a conversation with the then minister, but she said she was not sent the text until about fifteen minutes before a press comment was wanted. Having read it, she told the committee: "I unfortunately don't think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences." She also said she stands by paragraph 11.5 of her review, which says no LGBTQ+ person should be subjected to a conversion practice, and that these practices are abhorrent. I think we would all agree with that.

Why does Cass say the draft conversion practices bill is not tight enough?

She gave two reasons. The first is the test for health professionals: whether someone has fallen "far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position". She said there are no clear standards, and that standards in this area are highly contested, with many people disagreeing strongly with the approach recommended in her review. She worried that a young person who is upset, for example because they have not been put on the medication pathway they wanted, could report a clinician, and she mentioned people she called malign actors who encourage that. She said clinicians in the new gender services are concerned about vexatious complaints, and that the strain of going through a complaints process matters even when the clinician is cleared.

The second reason is parents. She said there is no intent to catch them, but that the way the bill is framed could reach a parent who does not agree to change pronouns for their child, or who restricts money because they think it will be spent on a breast binder or hormones.

Could parents who refuse pronouns or a binder be caught by the bill?

Cass said they potentially could, depending on how the draft is framed. I cannot tell you how the final wording will land, because the committee has not yet reported and the text can still change. What I can tell you is what those two examples are, from the point of view of a trans young person.

A parent refusing a name and pronouns, or refusing money for a binder, is not an abstract legal edge case to the young person on the receiving end. Those are exactly the experiences trans young people tell me hurt them very much: not being seen, not being named, not being recognised, being made to feel they are a problem that needs to be solved. Over the years I have met hundreds of trans people, children, young people and adults, and I have talked with their parents too. What I hear again and again is that the first thing a child needs when they tell you who they are is to be believed.

Belief is not a medical decision. It does not commit anyone to hormones or surgery. It says: I hear you, I love you, and I am not going to try to change who you are. The support, the questions and the decisions about care can follow from that, at the pace that is right for that young person. A parent who is frightened can do that first step today, with a name and a pronoun, and nothing in it needs a clinic.

Is clinicians' fear of complaints a reason to weaken a conversion practices ban?

The worry is real, and I understand it. Doctors and counsellors dread complaints, and a slow process is stressful even when it ends well. But a fear of process is an argument for a clear, well-drafted standard and a fair complaints system, not an argument for exemptions, because the law is there to protect the people with the least power, and in this conversation that is the trans child, not the adult who is uncomfortable.

It is also worth asking why a young person might be distressed at not reaching a medication pathway. In the UK, the sale and supply of puberty blockers on private prescription to trans young people has been banned, and NHS prescriptions are almost impossible to obtain because the services and expertise are not there. Young people pay for that in unwanted puberty changes, and their families pay in time, money and fear. The Cass Review led to that restriction and has been widely criticised by gender experts, who have published detailed rebuttals. A standard of care that a great many clinicians contest is a reason to write a clearer one, not a reason to leave a gap in a ban.

Should a conversion practices ban cover gender identity as fully as sexual orientation?

Yes, and that was the centre of my message to the committee. The ban should protect gender identity as fully as it protects sexual orientation, and it should not carry exemptions that allow the very practices it is meant to end to carry on. Any practice that sets out to stop a young person from being who they are harms them, however gently it is done and whatever it is called.

It does not matter whether it happens in a church, a doctor's consulting room, a counselling room or a family home. The intention is the same and so is the damage, which shows up in mental health, in trust in the adults around them, and in the years lost waiting to be allowed to live who they are. Counselling that helps someone navigate a decision is a good thing. Counselling that sets out to find the reason you are trans, or to steer you away from it, is something else.

Is "I don't believe who you are" a form of conversion therapy?

I think it is. Conversion therapy is not only elastic bands, vomiting and beatings. As I put it in my response, it is also "I don't believe who you are." Dr Helen Webberley, Gender Expert and Medical Educator, would say the same to any parent, teacher or doctor: the most protective thing an adult can do is believe the young person in front of them.

If you are a trans young person reading this and the people around you have not believed you yet, that is about them and not about you. Your identity does not depend on their agreement, and what you feel is real whether or not anyone has said so out loud.

What happens next, and when were these facts checked?

I checked the details here on 17 November 2026, against the committee session recording. The bill is still a draft under scrutiny, so its wording, the committee's report and any amendments can change. Re-check the current draft and the committee's published conclusions before relying on any detail about what the bill will or will not cover.

If there is a topic that you would like me to cover, just let Sammy know.

Dr Helen Webberley, Gender Expert and Medical Educator

Talk it through with Sammy

Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Everything here is education, not medical advice. If you're in crisis, call your local emergency services or visit helenwebberley.com/heretohelp.