Trans rights activists block EHRC building in Manchester Arndale
Trans rights activists blockaded the EHRC's Manchester Arndale offices to protest guidance that defines sex in strictly biological terms, saying it entrenches transphobia into law. The demonstration marked an early Transgender Day of Remembrance and ended when police and security removed protesters onto Market Street after around 25 minutes.
By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to The Mancunion17 November 20264 min read
Photo by Dylan4photography on Unsplash
Trans rights activists blockaded the Equality and Human Rights Commission's offices in Manchester Arndale, demonstrating against EHRC guidance that defines 'man', 'woman', and 'sex' in terms of biological sex. The protest marked an early commemoration of the Transgender Day of Remembrance, and ended when police and Arndale security removed protesters onto Market Street after roughly 25 minutes.
What happened at the Manchester Arndale
Activists from Young Struggle and other groups gathered first at Sackville Gardens, where they read speeches and held an early commemoration of the Transgender Day of Remembrance. Normally observed on 20 November, TDOR honours Rita Hester, a transgender woman killed in 1998, and all the trans people who have lost their lives since. One speech, sent in from Anakbayan, a Filipino youth organisation, commemorated the 2014 killing of Jennifer Laude, a Filipina trans woman, by a US marine stationed in the Philippines.
From Sackville Gardens the group walked through the city, taking to the roads with banners and flags, drawing attention with chants as they moved through the city centre. They reached Market Street at around 3:20pm, paused outside the building, and five minutes later entered the Arndale Centre. Video posted on Young Struggle's Instagram shows the group blocking the entrance to Arndale House, where the EHRC offices sit, chanting "we believe in liberation." Police and Arndale security removed them onto Market Street at 3:50pm. Officers followed the group until it dispersed.
What the protesters were objecting to
The target was the EHRC's recently published guidance, which defines 'man', 'woman', and 'sex' in terms of biological sex. Activists described it as "policies of repression" that "seek to entrench transphobia into law." They spoke in particular about what the guidance means for trans people in single-sex spaces, including public bathrooms, where the practical effect is that trans people can be excluded from spaces that match their gender.
They are not alone in that criticism. The guidance has been widely condemned as confusing and as inconsistent with Parliament's intent when it passed the Equality Act 2010. That Act protects trans people through the characteristic of gender reassignment, and the question of whether the EHRC's guidance reflects that protection or undermines it is not a settled one. The guidance is not statute; the Equality Act is, and conflating them does real harm.
The institution that was supposed to protect trans people
The EHRC was created to uphold equality for everyone. That means trans people. When activists stand outside its offices chanting "hands off our bodies," they are not making a symbolic gesture. They are describing something specific: the experience of watching an institution built to protect your rights become the institution enforcing their removal.
The EHRC publishing guidance that trans people say makes their daily lives harder, on a day chosen to remember trans people killed for being who they are, is not an irony but a precise illustration of what has gone wrong. The people marching through Manchester on that afternoon, naming Jennifer Laude and all the others, were not being dramatic. They were being accurate.
What the EHRC owes the people it has failed
The chant "hands off our bodies" is not abstract. It is about bathrooms, about safety, about whether you can get through a working day without being told that the law does not quite cover you in the way you thought it did. Trans people in this country are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for the protection that was written into law over a decade ago to actually apply to them.
The EHRC has a legal duty to promote equality and protect human rights, including those of trans people. The activists in Manchester were reminding it of that duty, loudly, in its own lobby. That is not a disruption to orderly process. That is the process working as it should, when every quieter route has already been tried.
If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert and Medical Educator, and the founder of GenderGP. She has spent her career listening to trans people and their families and working to make gender-affirming care accessible to everyone who needs it.
In response toTrans rights activists block EHRC building in Manchester ArndaleThe Mancunion
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments