EHRC chair urges calm while trans people avoid hospital
The EHRC chair says misinformation is driving trans anxiety, but Scottish Trans has told MSPs that trans people are refusing hospital treatment over fears about ward placement. When the guidance itself is producing that outcome, calling it a communications problem is the wrong diagnosis.
By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to The Guardian20 November 20264 min read
Photo by Amy Elting on Unsplash
Three trans people have refused to go to hospital against medical advice. Let that land for a moment before we talk about temperature.
At Holyrood on Thursday, Florence Oulds from Scottish Trans told MSPs exactly that. People frightened about where they would be placed on a ward, frightened enough to stay away from care they needed. That is what the EHRC's guidance has produced in practice, whatever the document intended in theory.
And the EHRC's response, through its chair Mary-Ann Stephenson, was to ask everyone to take the temperature down.
Who, exactly, is being asked to calm down?
I want to be fair to Stephenson here, because some of what she said at Holyrood is true. There has been inflated language on all sides. The guidance does not mandate genital checks. It does not, in its own words, exclude trans people from public life. Those specific claims are not accurate, and saying so is reasonable.
But there is a significant difference between correcting a specific misreading and telling the people most harmed by a policy to lower their anxiety. When you describe trans people's distress as a product of misinformation, you are, however gently, putting the problem in the wrong place.
The problem is not that trans people have misread the guidance. The problem is that the guidance is genuinely confusing, its effects are genuinely harmful, and the people experiencing those effects are trans people, not the equalities body sitting above the fray.
The document is the problem, not the response to it
Oulds was direct: the code of practice is "just fundamentally a very confusing and difficult document to follow." She described organisations that are genuinely trying to remain trans-inclusive, that want to do the right thing, that have paid for legal advice, and that have come away with completely conflicting answers about what compliance looks like.
Stephenson disagreed. She said she thought the code was "actually quite straightforward."
Those two positions cannot both be right. Either the code is clear and those organisations simply need to read it more carefully, or the code is producing wildly divergent legal interpretations and that is the code's fault. The evidence in front of the committee pointed strongly in one direction.
When an equalities body produces guidance that leads trans people to refuse hospital care, that is not a communications failure. That is the guidance doing harm.
Stephenson was right about one thing
She told MSPs: "It is really clear that there are significant numbers of trans people, including, particularly, maybe younger trans people, who feel very, very anxious at the moment."
Yes. And the reason younger trans people are especially anxious is that they are navigating an environment that has become measurably more hostile since the supreme court ruling, in ways that affect their daily lives: gyms, changing rooms, healthcare settings, leisure facilities. The ruling changed what they thought the law entitled them to, as Stephenson herself acknowledged. That is a loss. It deserves to be named as such, not filed under misinformation.
The anxiety is not a misunderstanding of the guidance. It is an accurate reading of what the guidance has meant in practice for people trying to live ordinary lives.
What the Equality Act was for
Stephenson invoked the heart of the Equality Act: building a society where everybody can live with dignity and access the services they need. I agree with that entirely. It is a good principle and I believe she means it.
But a trans person who will not go to hospital is not living with dignity. A trans person who cannot get a straight answer from their leisure centre is not accessing the services they need. The gap between the principle and the reality is what the committee was being shown, and asking people to take the temperature down does not close it.
The Equality Act 2010 is the law. The supreme court ruling is one interpretation of that Act. Interpretations can be wrong, and this one has been widely criticised as inconsistent with what Parliament intended. That is not inflamed language. That is a legal and democratic reality that the EHRC is in a position to acknowledge, and so far has not.
What actually needs to happen
What trans people in Scotland need is not calmer rhetoric. They need clarity about where they can access healthcare without fear, changing facilities without confrontation, and public services without being treated as a problem to be managed. They need guidance that organisations can actually follow, rather than guidance that sends them to lawyers and leaves them with contradictory advice.
Some of that is the EHRC's to fix. Some of it belongs to the Scottish Government, to the NHS, to service providers. But none of it gets fixed by asking the people bearing the cost to feel less strongly about it.
Three people stayed out of hospital. That is the number we have heard about. It will not be the whole number.
If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert and Medical Educator, and the founder of GenderGP. She writes about gender diversity, trans healthcare, and the lives at the centre of both.
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments