Underscores is first trans woman nominated for Best Dance/Electronic Recording Grammy

Underscores is now the first out transgender woman nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Dance/Electronic Recording, recognised for 'Music' from her album U. At the 2027 Grammys, trans women are making history across multiple categories, building on Kim Petras's 2023 win and the legacy of trans artists who came before.

By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to Billboard20 November 20264 min read

Underscores, the artist behind the track "Music" from her 2026 album U, has become the first out transgender woman ever nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Dance/Electronic Recording. Not the first trans woman to make music that deserved it, but the first to be nominated, and the difference between those two things is a story in itself.

The nomination, and what it actually says

The Grammy nomination list for Best Dance/Electronic Recording at the 2027 ceremony includes Madonna, Slayyyter, Tinashe, Fred again.., and Tame Impala. Underscores is on that list for "Music." Not as a curiosity, not as a symbolic gesture, but because the music earned its place there. That is the whole story, really. A trans woman made something good enough, and the Recording Academy put her name on the list. I find that genuinely wonderful.

The 2027 category is also notable for the number of women nominated. This is the first time four solo women acts have appeared in this category since 2000, when Cher won for "Believe." That context matters, because Underscores's nomination is part of a broader shift in who gets recognised in a category that has not always reflected the full range of people making dance and electronic music.

The trans women who came before her

Underscores did not arrive here from nowhere. The Billboard article names SOPHIE, Kim Petras, Arca, Honey Dijon, Wendy Carlos, Jackie Shane, and Teddy Geiger as trans women who received Grammy nominations over the years. Each of them made the space a little larger. SOPHIE, who died in 2021, changed what electronic music could sound like and what it could mean. Wendy Carlos brought synthesised music into the mainstream decades ago. These are not footnotes. They are the reason a nomination like this is possible.

In 2023, Kim Petras became the first transgender woman to win a Grammy, taking the award for Best Pop Duo/Group Performance for "Unholy" with Sam Smith. Her acceptance speech has stayed with me. She said: "I just want to thank all the incredible transgender legends before me who kicked these doors open for me so I could be here tonight. SOPHIE especially, my friend who passed away two years ago who told me this would happen and always believed in me." She thanked Madonna. And she thanked her mother, who believed her that she was a girl, growing up next to a highway in Germany. That speech was not a political statement. It was a thank-you note to everyone who made it possible for her to exist fully in the world. Underscores's nomination carries the same thread.

A wider moment at the 2027 Grammys

Underscores is not the only trans woman making history at the 2027 ceremony. Emily Green of Geese is the first out trans woman nominated for Best New Artist, as well as picking up nominations for Best Rock Performance, Best Alternative Music Performance, Best Alternative Music Album, and Best Rock Song. That is five nominations, five categories where a trans woman's name is on the list because the work demanded it.

This is what it looks like when trans people are allowed to be in the world, do their work, and be recognised for it. Not in spite of who they are, but because of everything they bring.

The comment left on the Billboard article

I did see the comment someone left beneath the Billboard article. It called Underscores a man, used male pronouns, and described her as mentally ill. I am naming it because ignoring it would be its own kind of dishonesty. That comment is wrong, and it is cruel. Underscores is a woman. The music is real. The nomination is real. One anonymous comment does not change any of that, and I will not let it crowd out the rest of this piece.

What I will say is this: the contrast between that comment and Kim Petras's acceptance speech, between that comment and the fact of Underscores's nomination, is itself a kind of answer. The music exists. The recognition exists. Trans women have always been here, making things, contributing beauty to the world. The people determined not to see that are going to have a harder and harder time looking away.

What this means

A trans woman made music she believed in. It was good enough to be nominated for the most significant music prize in the world. That is the story. It does not need to be more complicated than that, and it does not need to be less. I am delighted for Underscores, and I hope she knows how many people are rooting for her.

If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.

Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert and Medical Educator, and the founder of GenderGP. She writes about gender diversity, trans healthcare, and the lives at the centre of both.

In response toUnderscores Is First Transgender Woman Nominated for Best Dance/Electronic Recording GrammyBillboard

Talk it through with Sammy

Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Everything here is education, not medical advice. If you're in crisis, call your local emergency services or visit helenwebberley.com/heretohelp.