Hegseth calls trans people 'trannies' in Pentagon speech
Pete Hegseth, the US Defense Secretary, used a slur against trans people in an official Pentagon address, framing the removal of diversity programmes and the firing of senior military officers as a return to strength. The speech did not argue a case. It performed contempt, and that distinction matters.
By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to The New York Times5 October 20264 min read
Photo by Colin Lloyd on Unsplash
The line, delivered in what Hegseth called his "State of the Force" address, went like this: "No fanny — no fatties, no trannies, no beardos, no weirdos, no wimps, no radicals." It was presented as a translation of the phrase "no longer the woke department." It was delivered, apparently, as a crowd-pleaser.
That is easy to let the sheer brazenness of it carry you past what actually happened. A cabinet secretary, speaking in an official capacity about the armed forces of the United States, used a slur. Not in a private conversation that was later leaked. Not as an error he later corrected. As a deliberate rhetorical flourish, in a prepared speech, at a podium.
This is what dehumanisation looks like in practice
There is a version of this story that focuses on the political context, the culture war, the broader direction of the current administration. All of that is real and worth discussing. But I think the more important thing to name first is simpler: a human being used a slur to describe other human beings, in a room full of people who were apparently receptive to it, and called that leadership.
Trans people serve in the military. They have served for as long as there have been militaries, whether or not their identities were visible or acknowledged. The people Hegseth was describing with that word are real. Some of them may have been in uniform when he said it. Some of them may have been watching. What do you think it felt like to hear a government official reduce you to a punchline in a list that also includes "wimps" and "weirdos"?
This is not complicated language analysis. Calling someone a "tranny" is not a policy position; it is an insult, chosen specifically because it degrades. Using it from a position of institutional power, to justify removing people from their careers, is something else again.
What the speech was actually doing
Hegseth also used the address to defend the firing of dozens of admirals and generals, framing those who did not "respond positively" to his direction as people who had failed to grasp that civilian control of the military is not "simply a suggestion." That is a remarkable thing to say. Civilian control of the military is a foundational principle of democratic governance. Invoking it to justify removing officers who disagreed with you is using the language of constitutional order to do something closer to its opposite.
The logic of the speech is worth naming clearly. It goes like this: diversity is weakness, strength means exclusion, and anyone who disagreed with that has been removed. The circularity is intentional. By the time you have fired the people who might have pushed back, the remaining audience tends to applaud.
That is not a military that is more capable, it is a military that is more compliant, and historically, the distinction has mattered rather a lot.
The people this is actually about
Trans people who serve, or who wanted to serve, or who are simply watching this and wondering whether their government sees them as citizens, deserve something more than outrage on their behalf. They deserve honesty about what is happening.
What is happening is that a senior government official has used dehumanising language in an official setting and faced no apparent consequence for it. That language is not a distraction from policy; it is the policy made visible. The ban on trans military service, the removal of diversity programmes, the firing of officers who supported inclusion: these are the actions. The slur is what the actions sound like when the speaker stops choosing words carefully.
People tell me, again and again, that what they find hardest is not the formal restrictions, damaging as those are. It is the constant message that you are not fully real, not fully welcome, not quite a person in the eyes of those who hold power. A Defense Secretary using a slur in an official address is that message, delivered from the highest possible platform.
I hope the people hearing it know that the platform does not make it true.
If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert, Medical Educator, and founder of GenderGP. She writes about gender diversity, trans healthcare, and the lives at the centre of both.
In response toVideo: In Speech, Hegseth Targets Diversity and Transgender PeopleThe New York Times
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments