Judge dismisses lawsuit against NCAA over transgender athlete rule
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit against the NCAA brought by Riley Gaines and a group of athletes who claimed trans women in sport violated Title IX. The court found the NCAA is not covered by Title IX because it does not receive federal financial assistance. The case collapsed on a threshold question, and the noise around it was always louder than the legal substance.
By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to upi.com1 October 20265 min read
Photo by Braden Collum on Unsplash
A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit against the NCAA brought by Riley Gaines and a group of current and former college athletes, ruling that the NCAA is not covered by Title IX because it does not receive federal financial assistance. The case collapsed on a threshold question, and the noise around it was always louder than the legal substance beneath it.
What the lawsuit actually claimed
The case, filed in 2024, centred on a single event: the 2022 Women's Swimming and Diving Championships in Atlanta, where Lia Thomas, a transgender female swimmer competing for the University of Pennsylvania, entered the pool and won one race. One race. The plaintiffs, led by Riley Gaines, claimed that Thomas's presence at the event put them at a competitive disadvantage, bumped them from championship finals, and violated their privacy.
The legal vehicle was Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex-based discrimination in educational programmes that receive federal funding. The plaintiffs argued the NCAA qualified because of a concussion research partnership with the Department of Defense. U.S. District Court Judge Tiffany Johnson disagreed. The NCAA does not receive federal financial assistance in the way Title IX requires, and so the law simply does not apply. The case was over before it got started.
What the ruling does not say
This is the part that will get lost in the coverage. Judge Johnson did not rule that trans women belong in women's sport. She did not rule that they do not. She did not weigh evidence about competitive advantage, fairness, privacy, or inclusion. None of that was before her. The case was thrown out on a procedural threshold, not on its merits, and that distinction matters.
What the ruling does tell us is that the legal architecture of this particular lawsuit was shaky from the beginning. All the television appearances, all the hearings, all the political energy invested in this case, and it fell at the first hurdle. Riley Gaines has said she will appeal, which is her right, but the fundamental jurisdictional problem does not disappear on appeal unless new facts emerge about the NCAA's funding.
The context the story sits inside
The NCAA rescinded its policy allowing trans women to compete on women's teams the day after Donald Trump signed an executive order banning trans women from competition in February 2025. The U.S. Education Department has since urged the NCAA to erase records set by transgender athletes. Lia Thomas was not allowed to compete for a place on the U.S. women's swimming team at the Paris Olympics, and the Court of Arbitration for Sport dismissed her challenge to bans on trans athletes in women's events.
So the political project has largely succeeded, through executive power and institutional capitulation, even as this particular lawsuit has now failed. The athletes who brought this case wanted legal validation for a position the executive branch had already delivered to them through other means. They won the policy battle and lost the courtroom one.
Lia Thomas, one more time
I keep coming back to Lia Thomas throughout all of this, because she is the person at the centre of it and she tends to get treated as a symbol rather than a swimmer. She won one race at one championship. She also placed in the middle of the field in other events at that same championship. She trained, she competed, she followed the rules that were in place at the time. Then the rules changed, the bans came, and her name became attached to legislation, lawsuits, and executive orders across multiple countries.
That is a great deal to place on one person. Whatever anyone thinks about how sport should handle the inclusion of trans women, the treatment of Lia Thomas as a vehicle for a political argument rather than a human being who swam competitively is worth naming. She has been through the legal processes, the sporting bans, and the public campaign against her. The lawsuit that bore her name as its central exhibit has now been dismissed. She was not a party to it. She was simply the reason it existed.
What this ruling cannot do
It cannot settle the broader question, because that question is not a legal one at its core. How sport accommodates trans women, what policies are fair, how inclusion and competitive integrity relate to each other: these are questions that different sporting bodies, different countries, and different communities are answering in different ways, often without much evidence and often under significant political pressure.
What this ruling does do is confirm that the legal pathway chosen here did not hold up. That is not a vindication of trans inclusion in sport, and it is not a defeat for it either. It is a judge saying: this law does not apply to this organisation, and this case cannot continue on this basis.
The appeal will tell us whether that conclusion stands. In the meantime, the policy landscape has already moved far beyond the courtroom, and the people most affected by it, trans athletes trying to compete, train, and simply exist in sport, are living with consequences that no lawsuit outcome changes overnight.
If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley is a gender expert, medical educator, and advocate, and the founder of GenderGP.
In response toJudge dismisses lawsuit against NCAA over transgender athlete ruleupi.com
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments