Can parents opt children out of a trans teacher's class?

No court has ruled that parents can opt children out of a trans teacher's class on the basis of that teacher's identity alone. The Supreme Court's 2025 Mahmoud v. Taylor decision covered LGBTQ+-inclusive storybooks, not teachers. A trans woman doing her job is not curriculum content, and the legal effort to treat her as such is both novel and deeply revealing.

By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to WUNC News1 October 20266 min read

What actually happened in Wake County

This summer, a music teacher at Middle Creek Elementary in Apex, North Carolina was hired. She is a trans woman. She presents as a woman, uses female pronouns, and teaches music. That is the full extent of what she has done.

Republican state representative Erin Paré posted about it on X. Accounts like Libs of TikTok amplified it. Breitbart and Fox News picked it up. And suddenly a music teacher who had not given a single interview, who had simply shown up to do her job, found herself at the centre of a national story she never sought.

This woman is a teacher. She teaches children to sing, to read music, to love it. She has not discussed her identity with students. She has not done anything except exist while trans in a school, and that, apparently, is enough to generate threatening legal letters and national outrage.

What the parents are actually asking for

The parents working with the Thomas More Society, a conservative Catholic-affiliated law firm, are asking for several things. They want their children removed from her class. They want written assurance that gender identity will not be discussed. They want their children permitted to call her "Mr." and use male pronouns without facing any discipline. They want her excluded from shared restroom use with students. And they want no retaliation against children who opt out.

What they say they are not asking for is her dismissal. They are right that employment protections exist, and firing someone for being trans would be straightforwardly unlawful. But the list of demands amounts to something only marginally less harmful: publicly marking a teacher as a problem, stripping her of her professional title, and signalling to every student in that school that she is someone to be treated differently.

Becky Lew Hobbs of the Wake County chapter of Moms for Liberty framed it as parents having concerns about questions being raised in young children about sexuality and gender. But this teacher has not raised those questions. The parents and the press coverage have. Five, six, and seven-year-olds in that school are learning about gender because adults decided to make their teacher a controversy, not because she did anything to prompt it.

What the law actually says

The legal letter sent to Wake County schools leans heavily on Mahmoud v. Taylor, the Supreme Court's 2025 decision allowing parents to opt their children out of lessons where LGBTQ+-inclusive storybooks were used. The Court found that denying that opt-out likely violated parents' free exercise rights to direct the religious upbringing of their children.

Emily Gold Waldman, a law professor at Pace University who published a paper on these parental rights cases in the North Carolina Law Review, confirmed that this was a significant shift. Before Mahmoud, courts had generally held that parental rights were protected by the existence of alternatives: you could home-school or use private education. Mahmoud moved the line.

But there is a meaningful difference between a book that teaches about LGBTQ+ lives and a teacher who is trans. A storybook is curriculum content chosen by a school. A teacher's identity is not. She is not teaching about trans people. She is teaching music. Extending Mahmoud to cover a teacher's existence would be a substantial legal step, and no court has taken it.

North Carolina's 2023 Parents' Bill of Rights adds another thread. It includes a right to direct children's religious and moral upbringing, and there is now a state law allowing students to leave school for up to an hour a week for religious instruction. Parents are asking whether they can use that policy to pull children from the music class specifically. That is a creative argument. Whether it survives legal scrutiny is another matter entirely.

The playbook is not new

Cal Foshee, a Middle Creek Elementary parent who spoke in support of the teacher, put it plainly: "History tells us this playbook is nothing new. Fifteen years ago, these same hand-wringing arguments were used against gay teachers. Fifty years ago, they were used against Black teachers. It's the same exact intolerance repackaged for a new decade."

He is right, and it is worth naming that clearly. The argument being made is not really about curriculum content or religious freedom. It is about whether a trans woman is an appropriate presence in a school building at all. The demands around pronouns, restrooms, and opt-outs all point in the same direction: she should be made to feel that her presence is conditional, contested, and subject to veto.

Trans teachers exist. They have always existed. Many have taught generations of children who never knew, and whose lives were enriched by them. The only thing that has changed is that visibility has increased, and with it the organised effort to turn that visibility into a liability.

What this costs her

The teacher at the centre of this has given no interviews. She has asked for privacy. She has simply tried to do her job while a law firm, a national media cycle, and a school board controversy swirl around her without her participation.

I find that quietly heartbreaking. Not because she is a victim in any simple sense, but because this is what it still costs to be trans and employed in parts of the world in 2026. You can do everything right. You can show up, work hard, stay professional, and avoid the spotlight entirely. And it may still not be enough to be left alone to teach.

Wake County Public Schools, for their part, has said it has nothing to add. The Thomas More Society's deadline of 30 September has now passed. What happens next is uncertain.

What is not uncertain is this: a trans woman is a woman. A woman who teaches music is a music teacher. And the legal effort to make her identity a subject that children need protecting from is an argument built on a premise that is simply wrong.

If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.

Dr Helen Webberley is a Gender Expert, Medical Educator, writer, and advocate, and the founder of GenderGP.

In response toCan parents opt their children out of a transgender teacher's class? Here's what courts sayWUNC News

Talk it through with Sammy

Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Everything here is education, not medical advice. If you're in crisis, call your local emergency services or visit helenwebberley.com/heretohelp.