Northern Ireland hands Hilary Cass another gender services role
Health Minister Mike Nesbitt has asked Hilary Cass to assess Northern Ireland's gender identity services, including the planned Regional Lifespan Gender Service. The assessment was due to begin in November 2025. Because the Cass Review has been widely discredited, the framework steering care for trans people there is one many gender experts have rebutted.
By Dr Helen WebberleyResponding to health-ni.gov.uk21 July 20264 min read
Photo by K. Mitch Hodge on Unsplash
What has Northern Ireland actually announced?
On 4 September 2025, Mike Nesbitt announced that Baroness Cass, a retired consultant paediatrician and former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, would look at the actions being taken in Northern Ireland. The assessment will also consider the proposed Regional Lifespan Gender Service, which would bring the CAMHS Knowing Our Identity Team and the Adult Gender Service together under one management structure.
The Minister said he was "delighted" and called Baroness Cass "eminently qualified". He pointed to an already approved £806,000 business case, much of it for more psychological and psychiatric support and a more multi-disciplinary approach, and said: "From my reading of the Cass Review that is exactly the direction of travel she has recommended." He also said he was "content with the process" but that questions had been raised, and that an independent assessment might address them.
Read that again. The Minister has told us the service already matches the reviewer's views before the reviewer has begun, which is a verdict in advance, not an independent check.
What does it mean for trans people waiting in Northern Ireland?
Putting children's and adult services under one roof could be a good thing. People tell me all the time how much is lost when a young person is handed from one team to another, so I would not dismiss the idea of a single pathway. But read what the announcement does not say. Nothing about waiting times. Nothing about when anyone will be seen. Nothing about hormones. The money is described as going towards psychological and psychiatric support.
The notes to editors add that referral "is not gender affirming" and that it does not "imply automatic access to affirming treatments". Why does a health department feel the need to put that in writing? Nobody says it about a referral for a heart clinic. It treats affirming care as a risk to be disclaimed, rather than as healthcare that helps people.
The Minister also says Northern Ireland "rightly adopted" the recommendation on puberty blockers. Let me say what that costs. Blockers are medications that pause puberty, and they have been used for decades. Where they are withheld, puberty carries on, and every month of an unwanted one is a permanent change that young person did not choose. They pay for it, along with their families, who are left scrambling.
Why does exporting the Cass Review not make it sound?
The Minister says Baroness Cass found that most young people experiencing gender-related distress would not benefit from a medical pathway. That claim does not match the standards of care published by WPATH and the Endocrine Society guidelines, or the position of the major medical bodies. The Cass Review has been internationally discredited, and many gender experts have published detailed rebuttals. Part of the evidence it leaned on came from SEGM-linked work, a network that presents as research while functioning as a gatekeeper.
A flawed review does not become more reliable because a second health system borrows it. Applying it to a new set of trans people only spreads the same mistakes further. It also matters who is not mentioned in this announcement. The Minister, the Baroness and the business case are all named. Trans people in Northern Ireland, the ones who actually use the service, are not.
If you are in Northern Ireland and tired of waiting, you are not wrong to look elsewhere. GenderGP can help with access to affirming medical care, including hormones, blockers, prescribing and monitoring, while public services work out what they are doing. And if you want to talk through what any of this means for you, Sammy is here for exactly that.
If there is a news story you would like me to cover then just let Sammy know.
Dr Helen Webberley, Gender Expert, Medical Educator, writer and advocate
Talk it through with Sammy
Sammy has read this with you, and can help you work out what it means for you.
Comments